This is MUCH harder for me than it should be, primarily because there are actually two criteria that are equally important to us as a club:
1) whether it is well written, structured and articulated
2) whether the plot grips, transports and/or fascinates us.
I guess that the easy way would be to take both into consideration:
1-2 both the plot and writing are diabolical
3-4 one really sucks; the other is palatable
5-6 one is decent; the other is slightly better than that
7-8 one is great; the other just not quite
9-10 both the plot and writing are superlative
It seems to me pretty dry, lacking a certain pizazz or flare of imagination.
So, I'm appealing to y'all. If anyone has a better more book based system that they think would work for us, please Please PLEASE let me know!
1 comments :
Could you record a score for each criteria?
Then you could add them together for an overall score if required.
Post a Comment