“Let us read, and let us dance;
these two amusements will never do any harm to the world.”

Sunday, 14 August 2011

Book Club 5 - Soulless

I made this: Avid Reader at 2:57 pm
Date: June 2011
Time: 5pm - 7pm

Agreed on: The Line Of Beauty - Alan Hollinghurst

Discussed: Soulless by Gail Carriger

The first in the Parasol Protectorate series.

A polarising book - those who enjoyed it really did while those who didn't were equally vocal against it!

So bear in mind that for each positive or negative point, half of us totally disagreed.

Unfortunately, one or two members had thought that this was a young adult novel and had quite enjoyed it. Then, upon finding out that it wasn't, downgraded their opinion of it. As a YA book it was pretty good; as a book written for adults, they found it less enjoyable - though still better than Twilight! Comparisons were made to Point Horror, the Hardy Boys and Scooby Doo though most agreed that it was a very accessible read and those worked in libraries said they'd order the series in for sure.

A few of the book clubbers found the primary protagonist - Alexia - to be identifiable for the first half of the book. She was feisty, independent and forthright. Also kickass...but only when appropriately dressed! However, for the latter half of the book, her obsession with her male counterpart alienated some of us. 

Though this book was set in a steam punk world, there was surprisingly little detail about it. What there was painted an interesting picture of a world where supernaturals were accepted in a tolerate Victorian Britain. However, given the vast amount of actual technological advances made during this period, it was a shame that they weren't explored in more detail.  As one member put it 'too much supernatural romance, not enough steam punk world'.

On the other hand, the mythology of the supernaturals was interesting, particularly relating to their 'breeding'. (Then again there was a minority who thought that it was a shame that they used vampires and werewolves and failed to use any of the established mythology.)

Some felt that the supernatural romance was over-emphasised taking from the overall mystery of the book. There were certainly some very inappropriate make out sessions - like right in the middle of an escape or while someone (a supposed friend) was being tortured. As a love story; it was both obvious and really poorly explored. Alexia seemed to fall in love primarily because SOMEONE was attracted to her. 

The morality element was also mentioned. Despite being a very forward thinking woman; Alexia required a firm committment before proceding sexually - despite being prepared to go considerably more forward than other ladies of the time.

Another mentioned their irritation at the perspective shown regarding scientists. Progress and technology were always shown in a negative light, while 'natural' things were seen as being cute and cuddly. There was no acknowledgement on all the cultural aspects that have evolved from the pursuit of knowledge. 

A common complaint was the language used. The book lacked structure and was in places clumsy without subtlety.

However, what really irked was that there were unanswered questions at the end of the book. Soulless was an obvious scene setter, never meant to stand alone. Personally, I found this to be rather arrogant on behalf of the author. 

The Verdict


Next Book Choice!

The Line Of Beauty - Alan Hollinghurst  
This was the Man Booker Prize in 2004

We had a rather delicious cinnamon crumble cake provided for us by @meulop! 

The recipe is now available in our sweet tooth section!!

* * * * * 
Arcadia LBC

21 - Nov - Hard Times - Charles Dickens
20 - Oct - The New York Trilogy - Paul Auster GUEST - @CultureLEEDS
19 - Sep - The Hunger Games - Suzanne Collins GUEST - @CultureLEEDS
18 - Aug - The Princess Bride - William Goldman
17 - Jul - A Thousand Splendid Suns - Khaled Hosseini GUEST
16 - Jun - Cry the Beloved Country - Alan Paton
15 - May - 1984 - George Orwell GUEST - @CultureLEEDS
14 - Apr - BloodChild and Other Stories - Octavia Butler
13 - Mar - The Year of the Hare - Arto Paasilinna
12 - Feb - Heat Wave - Richard Castle
11 - Jan - The Miracle Life of Edgar Mint - Brady Udall
10 - Nov - Flowers for Algernon - Daniel Keyes

* * * * *
Book Club - Table of Contents

* * * * *



Leeds Book Club Copyright © 2010 Designed by Ipietoon Blogger Template Sponsored by Online Shop Vector by Artshare